Indulge in Autumn: Your Guide to the Perfect Pumpkin Spice Bourbon Old Fashioned

Kick off September and embrace the cozy vibes of fall with a delightful Pumpkin Spice Bourbon Old Fashioned! This simple yet sophisticated cocktail elevates the classic Old Fashioned with a homemade pumpkin spice simple syrup, infusing it with layers of warm, aromatic autumn flavors. It truly is pumpkin, spice, and everything nice, bottled in a glass.

Embracing the Fall Spirit: The Pumpkin Spice Bourbon Old Fashioned

As the leaves begin to turn and the air gets crisp, there’s nothing quite like a warm, spiced drink to celebrate the changing seasons. Even if it’s still warm outside, the moment September arrives, our hearts long for those unmistakable autumn flavors. That’s exactly why this Pumpkin Spice Bourbon Old Fashioned is the perfect concoction to usher in fall. It marries the robust character of bourbon with the sweet, aromatic notes of pumpkin and classic fall spices, creating a truly unforgettable experience.

This isn’t just another pumpkin-flavored drink; it’s a carefully balanced cocktail that honors the integrity of the Old Fashioned while introducing a seasonal twist. The secret lies in the homemade pumpkin spice simple syrup, which infuses the drink with genuine pumpkin flavor and a hint of spice, all without overwhelming the sophisticated profile of the bourbon. The result is a smooth, inviting drink that’s both comforting and elegant.

Forget overly complicated recipes or a long list of obscure ingredients. This cocktail is designed for simplicity and maximum flavor impact. With just a few core components – a good bourbon, your special pumpkin spice simple syrup, and a dash of bitters – you’ll have a bartender-quality drink ready in minutes. It’s the ideal way to unwind after a long day or to impress guests at your next fall gathering.

Key Ingredients for Your Autumn Elixir

Crafting a superb Old Fashioned, especially one with a seasonal twist, begins with selecting the right ingredients. Each component plays a vital role in building the complex and harmonious flavor profile of this autumnal cocktail.

• Bourbon: The Heart of the Drink. For a bourbon-forward cocktail like this, the quality of your whiskey truly shines through. While you don’t need to splurge on a top-shelf bottle, opting for a nice mid-price range bourbon is highly recommended. Brands like Bulleit, Knob Creek, or Woodford Reserve offer excellent balance, a smooth finish, and rich notes that complement the pumpkin spice beautifully. Avoid anything too harsh or too delicate; you want a bourbon that can hold its own against the syrup and bitters. Look for bourbons with caramel, vanilla, or oak notes to enhance the fall flavors.
• Pumpkin Spice Simple Syrup: The Flavor Star. This homemade syrup is the secret weapon for this cocktail. It’s incredibly easy to whip up at home with just a few basic ingredients, offering a far more authentic and nuanced flavor than many store-bought alternatives. The syrup introduces a delicate sweetness alongside the comforting essence of pumpkin and a medley of fall spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove. Beyond this cocktail, it’s remarkably versatile – try it in your morning coffee, drizzled over pancakes, or even as a topping for vanilla ice cream throughout the fall season!
• Bitters: The Balancing Act. Bitters are essential in any Old Fashioned, acting as the cocktail’s seasoning. They introduce aromatic complexity and help to balance the sweetness of the syrup and the intensity of the bourbon. For this Pumpkin Spice Old Fashioned, I highly recommend using orange or smoked orange bitters. The citrus notes beautifully complement the pumpkin and spice, adding a bright, zesty counterpoint. However, other citrus bitters would also work wonderfully, so feel free to experiment with what you have on hand.
• Ice: The Chilling Factor. While not a flavor ingredient, the type of ice you use significantly impacts the drink. Large ice cubes or spheres are preferred as they melt slower, chilling your drink without over-diluting it, allowing you to savor the rich flavors longer.

Essential Bar Tools for the Perfect Stir

While making an Old Fashioned might seem straightforward, having the right tools can elevate your home bartending experience from good to exceptional. These “must-haves” ensure your Pumpkin Spice Bourbon Old Fashioned is perfectly mixed and presented.

• Sphere Ice Molds or Large Ice Cube Trays: If you don’t already own them, investing in sphere ice molds or extra-large cube trays is a game-changer for any Old Fashioned enthusiast. Large ice melts much slower than standard cubes, preventing your drink from becoming watered down too quickly. This allows the intricate flavors of the bourbon and pumpkin spice syrup to be enjoyed at their best, maintaining the perfect chill without compromising the taste. Plus, a large ice sphere looks incredibly elegant in a glass!
• Double Old Fashioned Glasses (Rocks Glasses): The right glass makes a difference not just aesthetically, but also functionally. Double Old Fashioned glasses, also known as rocks glasses, are designed to accommodate large ice cubes or spheres and provide ample space for stirring. Their sturdy base and wide rim are classic for a reason, enhancing the drinking experience.
• Bar Spoon: A long-handled bar spoon is essential for properly stirring an Old Fashioned. Unlike shaking, which aerates and dilutes a drink, stirring gently combines the ingredients, ensuring they are thoroughly mixed and chilled without introducing unwanted air bubbles or excessive dilution. The length allows you to reach the bottom of your glass or mixing glass with ease.
• Jigger or Measuring Spoons: While not strictly a “must-have” if you’re experienced, a jigger (a bartender’s measuring tool) or even standard measuring spoons are invaluable for precision. Cocktails, especially those with strong spirits and syrups, benefit greatly from accurate measurements to achieve the perfect balance of flavors.
• Mixing Glass: Although you can stir directly in your serving glass, a dedicated mixing glass allows for better temperature control and a more consistent stir before pouring into your chilled rocks glass.

Crafting Your Pumpkin Spice Old Fashioned: Step-by-Step

Stir & Serve: The Art of Simplicity

One of the beauties of an Old Fashioned is its deceptive simplicity. There’s no shaking required, no fancy techniques – just a gentle stir to combine the harmonious flavors. This cocktail is literally as simple as combining your ingredients and serving, making it approachable for even the most novice home bartender.

Here’s a slightly more detailed guide to ensure perfection:

1. Chill Your Glass: Start by placing a large ice cube or sphere into your double Old Fashioned glass. You can also briefly chill your glass in the freezer before adding ice for an extra cold drink.
2. Add Ingredients: Pour in the bourbon, followed by the pumpkin spice simple syrup, and finally, your chosen bitters (orange or smoked orange are ideal). Precision here ensures a balanced drink, so use a jigger if you have one.
3. Stir Gently: Using your bar spoon, gently stir the ingredients in the glass for about 20-30 seconds. The goal is to thoroughly combine and chill the drink without over-diluting it. You’ll notice the liquid becoming slightly colder and more uniform in color.
4. Garnish (Optional, but Recommended): A strip of orange peel, expressed over the drink to release its aromatic oils, adds a beautiful citrus note and visual appeal. A cinnamon stick can also be added for an extra layer of spice and a festive touch.
5. Serve Immediately: Enjoy your perfectly crafted Pumpkin Spice Bourbon Old Fashioned right away!

See? How incredibly simple is that for such a sophisticated and flavorful cocktail?

More Old Fashioned Recipes to Explore: Apple Pie Old Fashioned / Earl Grey Old Fashioned / Smoked Orange Old Fashioned / Jameson Old Fashioned

Bourbon vs. Rye: The Old Fashioned Debate

The Old Fashioned is a timeless classic, and at its heart is whiskey. While it is true that a traditional Old Fashioned is most commonly and historically made with bourbon, rye whiskey is also a popular choice among enthusiasts. The key difference lies in their flavor profiles: bourbon tends to be sweeter and smoother, with notes of vanilla, caramel, and oak, due to its corn-heavy mash bill. Rye, on the other hand, is spicier, drier, and more peppery, offering a sharper, bolder taste.

For this particular Pumpkin Spice Bourbon Old Fashioned, I strongly recommend sticking with bourbon. The inherent sweetness and mellow characteristics of bourbon provide a perfect foundation for the pumpkin spice simple syrup. Rye whiskey’s distinct spicy notes, while delicious in other cocktails, could potentially clash with or overpower the delicate balance of the pumpkin and fall spices, altering the overall intended flavor profile too much. Bourbon creates a smoother, more integrated autumnal experience, allowing all the flavors to harmonize beautifully.

Need some more inspiration for cocktail hour? Check out my Booze Recipes page!

The Magic of Homemade Pumpkin Spice Simple Syrup

The star ingredient that truly transforms this into a *Pumpkin Spice* Old Fashioned is, of course, the pumpkin spice simple syrup. And the best part? It’s incredibly easy to make right in your own kitchen! Forget about those overly sweet, artificial-tasting store-bought syrups. Crafting it yourself ensures a fresh, authentic flavor that you can customize to your liking.

The pumpkin spice simple syrup recipe only requires a few basic ingredients – pumpkin puree, sugar, water, and a blend of classic fall spices. It takes mere minutes to simmer on the stovetop, and once cooled, it can be stored in an airtight container in your refrigerator for days, if not weeks. This means you can whip up a batch on a Sunday and enjoy multiple cocktails (or other pumpkin-spiced treats) throughout the week without extra effort.

Beyond its use in this incredible bourbon cocktail, this versatile syrup is a fantastic addition to many other beverages and dishes. Stir it into your morning coffee or afternoon iced tea for a homemade pumpkin spice latte experience. Drizzle it over pancakes, waffles, or oatmeal for an autumn-inspired breakfast. It’s also divine over plain yogurt or ice cream. Making your own syrup is not only a delightful culinary adventure but also a smart way to save money and ensure you’re enjoying the freshest, most flavorful pumpkin spice fix at home.

Perfect Pairings for Your Fall Cocktail

The Pumpkin Spice Bourbon Old Fashioned is a fantastic drink that stands proudly on its own, offering a complex blend of flavors perfect for a quiet evening. However, its robust yet nuanced profile also makes it incredibly versatile for pairing with a variety of fall seasonal flavors, especially when entertaining. Its warmth and spice make it an excellent companion to rich, savory, and subtly sweet dishes.

If you’re hosting a fall gathering, consider setting up a self-serve cocktail station. This allows guests to personalize their drinks and frees you from bartending duties! Simply set out the bourbon, pumpkin spice simple syrup, bitters, and ice, along with a framed card listing the measurements and simple instructions. Don’t forget your bar tools (jigger, bar spoon) and garnishes (orange peels, cinnamon sticks) for a professional touch.

For party bites and appetizers that beautifully complement this cocktail, here are some recommendations:

• Butternut Squash Goat Cheese Empanadas: The creamy, tangy goat cheese and sweet butternut squash wrapped in a crispy pastry offer a delightful contrast to the bourbon’s warmth.
• BBQ Pulled Pork Sliders with Apple Coleslaw: The smoky, sweet, and savory notes of pulled pork, especially with a hint of apple, create a fantastic harmony with the spiced bourbon.
• Air Fryer Buffalo Jalapeño Poppers: If you like a little kick, the heat from the jalapeño and the richness of the cheese are wonderfully balanced by the bourbon and the subtle sweetness of the syrup.

And for a full fall-themed dinner experience, consider pairing your cocktail with these creative Pumpkin Spice Chicken Tacos. It’s an unexpected but incredibly flavorful twist that continues the autumn spice theme throughout your meal.

Finally, I love hearing from you! If you make this Pumpkin Spice Bourbon Old Fashioned, please be sure to give the recipe a rating or leave a comment below. Your feedback means the world to me, and I take the time to respond to every single comment. Don’t hesitate to drop any questions you might have. And for an extra sprinkle of joy, tag me on Instagram (@cakenknife) if you share your creations! Seeing these recipes come to life in your homes is truly my favorite thing.

Pumpkin Spice Bourbon Old Fashioned

Pumpkin spice simple syrup takes this classic bourbon old fashioned to a whole new level! It’s the ideal simple cocktail for fall.

Prep Time:
5 minutes mins

Total Time:
5 minutes mins

Servings:
1 cocktail

No ratings yet

Print

Pin

cook modeprevent your screen from going dark

Equipment

• Cocktail Stirring Spoons
• Sphere Ice Molds
• Rocks Glasses

Ingredients

• 2 oz your favorite bourbon
• 1 oz Pumpkin Spice Simple Syrup
• 2 dashes orange or citrus bitters

Instructions

• Add bourbon, Pumpkin Spice Simple Syrup, and bitters to a double old fashioned cocktail glass that has a large ice cube in it.
• Stir to combine.
• Serve.

Cuisine: Fall Cocktails

Category: Booze